FIFTY-FIFTY Memory-Foam vs Selle Royal Freeway Fit
Two comfort-cutout saddles aimed at upright riders - one a $38 Amazon-native upgrade from FIFTY-FIFTY, the other a $58 mainstay from Italy's Selle Royal. Padding, channel design, and width sizing decide which one is the better seat for a hybrid, commuter, or e-MTB.
- Weight: ~340 g
- Shell: nylon composite
- Padding: memory foam
- Cutout: central pressure-relief channel
- Cover: waterproof microfiber
- Rails: chromoly steel
- Width: single (~175 mm)
Sizing: Single width (~175 mm) - good for wider sit-bones (130-160 mm range) but no S/M/L sizing if your sit-bones are narrower. Standard chromoly rails. 2024 refresh adds the central cutout that was missing from the original.
MSRP: $33-42 · Amazon ~$37.99
- Weight: 310-350 g
- Shell: composite
- Padding: gel comfort layer
- Cutout: yes (central channel)
- Rails: steel
- Widths: 145 mm / 160 mm / 175 mm
- Length: 270 mm
Sizing: Three widths (145, 160, 175 mm) sized to sit-bone width 130-175 mm - the only saddle of the two with a true fit system. Gel padding instead of memory foam holds shape longer.
MSRP: $50-80 · Amazon ~$57.70
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. This helps support our free calculators.
Side-by-side spec sheet
| Aspect | FIFTY-FIFTY Memory-Foam MTB Saddle 2024 | Selle Royal Freeway Fit | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Weight | ~340 g | 310-350 g | Tie |
| Padding type | Memory foam | Gel comfort | Freeway Fit |
| Pressure-relief cutout | Yes (channel) | Yes (channel) | Tie |
| Width options | 1 (~175 mm) | 3 (145 / 160 / 175 mm) | Freeway Fit |
| Cover material | Waterproof microfiber | Selle Royal microfiber | Tie |
| Rails | Chromoly steel | Steel | Tie |
| Brand pedigree | Amazon-native budget | Italian heritage, 65+ years | Freeway Fit |
| Amazon price | $37.99 | $57.70 | Saddle 2024 |
The verdict
Pick the Selle Royal Freeway Fit if you want a saddle sized to your sit-bone width - the 145/160/175 mm widths and gel padding hold shape for years of commuting and the Italian build is famously durable. Pick the FIFTY-FIFTY Memory-Foam Saddle 2024 if you have wider sit-bones, want softer initial feel from memory foam rather than gel, and can save $20 on what is fundamentally a similar comfort-cutout shape. The FIFTY-FIFTY only ships in one width, so measure your sit-bones first.
Best value
FIFTY-FIFTY Memory-Foam MTB Saddle 2024 - $19.71 cheaper for a saddle with the same cutout, similar weight, and comparable padding feel. The Selle Royal earns its premium with sit-bone-width sizing, but a wider rider who knows they fit the 175 mm bracket loses nothing by going FIFTY-FIFTY.
Best performance
Selle Royal Freeway Fit - three widths means a real sit-bone fit instead of guessing, gel keeps its shape longer than memory foam, and Selle Royal's QC across decades is the safer commuter bet.
More saddles comparisons
Not sure which saddles fits you?
Our sizing guides and category pages help you narrow the field.