Skip to main content
BikeSize
Saddles

FIFTY-FIFTY Memory-Foam vs Selle Royal Freeway Fit

Two comfort-cutout saddles aimed at upright riders - one a $38 Amazon-native upgrade from FIFTY-FIFTY, the other a $40 mainstay from Italy's Selle Royal. Padding, channel design, and width sizing decide which one is the better seat for a hybrid, commuter, or e-MTB.

Quick picks for different riders

Touring riders considering a traditional leather saddle

It depends on your priorities. Neither listing identifies a leather touring saddle.

Riders choosing around pressure relief and position

It depends on your priorities. Use sit-bone width and posture guidance; the catalog does not establish universal comfort.

Riders replacing a saddle on an existing seatpost

It depends on your priorities. Compare rail and mounting compatibility and exact saddle dimensions.

Check price: FIFTY-FIFTY Memory-Foam MTB Saddle 2024Check price: Selle Royal Freeway Fit

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Purchases made through these links help support our free calculators.

At a glance

Product details for FIFTY-FIFTY Memory-Foam MTB Saddle 2024 and Selle Royal Freeway Fit
DetailFIFTY-FIFTY Memory-Foam MTB Saddle 2024Selle Royal Freeway Fit
CategorySaddlesSaddles
LevelThe listing does not state an experience level; its product type is comfort.The listing does not state an experience level; its product type is commuter.
Key featuresShell: nylon composite with central cutout; Padding: memory foam over a breathable channel; Cover: waterproof microfiber; Rails: chromoly steel; Touring-compatible nose shape; Weight: ~340 gweight: 310-350 g; rails: steel; padding: gel comfort; cutout: yes (channel); length: 270 mm
What is includedThe catalog does not itemize box contents beyond the named product. Check the exact offer for included hardware or accessories.The catalog does not itemize box contents beyond the named product. Check the exact offer for included hardware or accessories.
Best forThe catalog’s fit/use note: 2024 refresh of the comfort saddle above - adds a central pressure-relief cutout and a slightly narrower nose for touring use. Same chromoly rail spec so it fits the same seatpost clamps. Pick this one over the original B0BJ8SX1ZC if you ride longer than 30 min at a time - the cutout matters at that range.The catalog’s fit/use note: Available widths 145, 160, 175 mm; fits sit-bone 130-175 mm
Main drawbackFit/use caveat recorded in the catalog: 2024 refresh of the comfort saddle above - adds a central pressure-relief cutout and a slightly narrower nose for touring use. Same chromoly rail spec so it fits the same seatpost clamps. Pick this one over the original B0BJ8SX1ZC if you ride longer than 30 min at a time - the cutout matters at that range.Fit/use caveat recorded in the catalog: Available widths 145, 160, 175 mm; fits sit-bone 130-175 mm

Specs and included items reflect the cited product listings; check the seller page for current package details.

Head-to-head criteria

Shape or pressure reliefDepends
FIFTY-FIFTY Memory-Foam MTB Saddle 2024Shell: nylon composite with central cutout
Selle Royal Freeway Fitcutout: yes (channel)
Padding or materialDepends
FIFTY-FIFTY Memory-Foam MTB Saddle 2024Padding: memory foam over a breathable channel
Selle Royal Freeway Fitpadding: gel comfort
Fit or sizeDepends
FIFTY-FIFTY Memory-Foam MTB Saddle 2024Not specified in catalog entry
Selle Royal Freeway FitNot specified in catalog entry
Weight, rails, or clampDepends
FIFTY-FIFTY Memory-Foam MTB Saddle 2024Rails: chromoly steel
Selle Royal Freeway Fitweight: 310-350 g
Current catalog priceOption A
FIFTY-FIFTY Memory-Foam MTB Saddle 2024$37.99
Selle Royal Freeway Fit$39.99

Meet the two options

FIFTY-FIFTY Memory-Foam MTB Saddle 2024
Option A

FIFTY-FIFTY Memory-Foam MTB Saddle 2024

Fifty Fifty · Comfort

The catalog lists FIFTY-FIFTY Memory-Foam MTB Saddle 2024 with Shell: nylon composite with central cutout; Padding: memory foam over a breathable channel; Cover: waterproof microfiber; Rails: chromoly steel.

  • Shell: nylon composite with central cutout
  • Padding: memory foam over a breathable channel
  • Cover: waterproof microfiber
  • Rails: chromoly steel
  • Touring-compatible nose shape
  • Weight: ~340 g
Sizing: 2024 refresh of the comfort saddle above - adds a central pressure-relief cutout and a slightly narrower nose for touring use. Same chromoly rail spec so it fits the same seatpost clamps. Pick this one over the original B0BJ8SX1ZC if you ride longer than 30 min at a time - the cutout matters at that range.
MSRP: $33-42 · Amazon ~$37.99
Check price
Selle Royal Freeway Fit
Option B

Selle Royal Freeway Fit

Selle Royal · Commuter

The catalog lists Selle Royal Freeway Fit with weight: 310-350 g; rails: steel; padding: gel comfort; cutout: yes (channel).

  • weight: 310-350 g
  • rails: steel
  • padding: gel comfort
  • cutout: yes (channel)
  • length: 270 mm
Sizing: Available widths 145, 160, 175 mm; fits sit-bone 130-175 mm
MSRP: $35-$46 · Amazon ~$39.99
Check price

Other options to consider

Final verdict

Neither saddle can be named the better fit from a spec list alone. FIFTY-FIFTY Memory-Foam MTB Saddle 2024 is listed with shell: nylon composite with central cutout and padding: memory foam over a breathable channel; Selle Royal Freeway Fit lists cutout: yes (channel) and padding: gel comfort. Compare sit-bone width, riding position, rails, and exact dimensions, then use the maker’s fit advice. Catalog prices are $37.99 and $39.99, but price does not predict comfort. BikeSize has not fit-tested or ridden either saddle. If possible, try the shape on your bike before deciding.

Frequently asked questions

How we compared them

This comparison uses public manufacturer and product-listing details recorded for FIFTY-FIFTY Memory-Foam MTB Saddle 2024 and Selle Royal Freeway Fit in the BikeSize accessory catalog, including stated specifications, fit/use notes, and catalog prices. Claims are public evidence, not independent results. BikeSize did not buy, wear, ride, install, or hands-on test either product and conducted no comparative lab or performance testing.

More saddles comparisons

Bell Comfort Sport Seat vs Brooks England B17
Bell Comfort Sport Seat vs Ergon SM Sport Men S/M
Brooks England B17 vs Ergon SM Sport Men S/M

Not sure which saddles fits you?

Our sizing guides and category pages help you narrow the field.

Saddles sizing calculatorAll saddlesSaddles buying guideAll comparisons